Helpline 07939 046 030

Visible Difference Equality Law Research: summary of findings

07 November 2019

Visible Difference Equality Law Research: summary of findings

Below are the results of the study carried out by Hannah Saunders Durham CELLS (Centre for Ethics and Law in the Life Sciences) a study that we previously shared with our community in 2018. 

The research aimed to explore experiences relating to visible difference equality and the law. Seventeen interviews with volunteer participants were included within the project analysis, and five key themes were identified:

Theme 1: Me and visible difference – a complex equation of how I feel

Almost everyone expressed feelings of low confidence and / or self-consciousness related to visible difference at different times of their life. But there are various factors which some people believed impacted on the way they felt - such as fluctuations in the severity of their condition, self-acceptance, gender, age and level of job experience. There was not one unified picture of ‘what helps’ and ‘what hinders’. What the accounts did suggest, though, is that visible difference cannot be understood as an isolated, sole determinant of people’s experiences; the importance of other aspects of life -  such as friends and family, pride in one’s job and in one’s own skills, or a role helping others – are also integral to the experiences recounted.  

 

Theme 2: Me, you and visible difference – balancing coping and explaining against privacy

This theme relates to how people cope with having a visible difference in their daily lives. People talked about a variety of proactive and reactive coping strategies - such as explaining, hiding one’s difference or insecurity, and taking support from relevant charities and others in a similar position. Sometimes coping strategies seemed to focus more on self-protection - such as applying for manageable roles. While explaining is a common strategy, it wasn’t always simple; people often factor in various different things when deciding whether to 'explain' their condition to others. Some people seemed to feel a conflict between a desire to explain and a resentment about having to. 

 

Theme 3: Me, visible difference and work – my health needs and my job in conflict

This theme relates to the tension between what people felt was good for their health, and what they felt was required for their jobs. People often felt conflicted between the two, or forced to prioritise one over the other. 

 

Theme 4: Me, visible difference and society – feeling that I fall between the cracks

Many participants seemed to feel that their condition made them fall between the cracks. Legally, not everyone was aware of the law, and people often did not self-identify as disabled. This created a dilemma for many people on whether to disclose a condition during recruitment.  Some wanted employers to have a more flexible approach to health, rather than a tick box 'disabled or not' approach which exacerbates this dilemma.
In health terms, the feeling of falling between the cracks related to both a lack of understanding about some conditions and, for some, a need to battle for treatment because their condition is seen as 'cosmetic' or given low priority for care. 

Socially, many people had, at some stage in their lives, felt that visible difference prevented them from fitting in; some felt overlooked, harassed or targeted in the workplace. A feeling of their condition being misunderstood or underestimated by colleagues was also commonly cited. However, there were also very many positive stories of inclusion at work; people with good friends and supportive colleagues, many of whom enjoy their job.

 

Theme 5: Me, visible difference and rights – moral duties to be wary of

In generic terms, rights were seen almost as a moral duty: something that should be enforced if needed, to stand up for myself or to prevent the same thing from happening to others. However, people were wary about the reality of enforcing rights - both in terms of  challenging discrimination, or having reasonable adjustments made (if appropriate). There was also a strong sense in some interviews that rights are only positive if handled in a certain way - there is the potential for them to become 'wrongs' if dealt with inappropriately by others. 

 

What happens now with the research?

The interviews are part of a wider research project and provide an important contribution to evaluating whether the law is working properly. The research suggests that there may be some problems with the way the law works, and that some legal changes would be beneficial, including amended definitions, and increased guidance. The researcher hopes that these findings will open a debate about these important issues.

Filter News

Filter by Date
Category
Reset

Graham’s Super Nine Shines A Light on NF

Graham's 7 year old great-nephew Nathan is his inspiration for his epic challenges to fundraise for NTUK

Read More

Alice’s NF2 study project

Alice describes her NF2 study project as part of her Genetic and Genomic Counselling MSc

Read More

Poppy’s NF1 story

Poppy describes growing up with NF1 and fundraising for future research & treatment

Read More

Meeting Alpha FX

NTUK Head Office visited Alpha FX to give a presentation on our work & how their support & donations help the NF Community

Read More

Nerve Tumours UK joins the Neurological Alliance

A coalition of over 70 organisations working together to transform quality of life for people with neurological conditions.

Read More

Nerve Tumours UK Conference 2021

The first meeting since 2019 with our Specialist NF Advisors & Nurses, Head Office & Members of the Board of Trustees

Read More

Tricia’s Wingwalk fundraiser

Tricia describes her wingwalk experience in celebration of her 75th birthday and in memory of her daughter Sarah, who had NF1

Read More

Stuart’s Schwannoma story

Stuart describes how certain symptoms led to a Schwannoma discovery

Read More

Joy’s NF1 story

Joy describes living with NF1; her son's diagnosis and support at school; fundraising and shining a light on NF

Read More