The Royal Society - A Quest for the perfect Human…? A debate on the implications of human genome editing
21 November 2019


The Royal Society - A Quest for the perfect Human...? A debate on the implications of human genome editing
Nerve Tumours UK were delighted to be invited to attend the debate held at The Royal Society on Tuesday 12 November 2019. The charity was represented on all fronts by Karen Cockburn, Charity Director, Alice Rosen, Fundraising Manager, Carolyn Smyth, Lead Specialist NF Nurse and Richard Goode, Trustee.
The Royal Society is a Fellowship of many of the world's most eminent scientists and is the oldest scientific academy in continuous existence. The Society’s purpose is to recognise, promote and support excellence in science for the benefit of humanity.
The debate was very well attended with many interested, and some quite distinguished, professionals; and other organisations such as Genetic Alliance and Genetic Disorders UK. This promised to be a fascinating insight into the world of cutting-edge research, and we were not disappointed.
So, what was it all about? I will attempt to enlighten you.
CRISPER cas-9 is technology that allows scientists to make changes to DNA in cells that could potentially allow us to cure genetic diseases.
CRISPR CAS-9 is an acronym:
C- Clustered
R- Regularly
I- Interspaced
S- Short
P- Palandromic
R- Repeats
cas-9 is a protein.
Jennifer Doudner, a Biochemist and Emmanuele Charpentier, a French Professor and Researcher specialising in genetics and microbiology were collaborating on an entirely different project when they realised the potential implications of their discovery.
The CRISPR - cas9 discovery was co-incidental to a basic research project aimed at discovering how bacteria fights viral infections. Many bacteria have in their cells an adapted immune system allowing them to detect viral DNA and destroy it.
Part of the CRISPR system is a protein known as cas-9. It is able to seek out and cut / degrade viral DNA. It was as a result of this that the researchers realised that these functions could be used in genetic engineering to delete or insert specific bits of DNA into cells with incredible precision. Therefore, this could offer opportunities to do things that had not been possible before.
The programme for the debate

Genome engineering is not new and has been in development since the 1970's and some of the first applications for this included copying and manipulating DNA. However, this technology raises a number of ethical questions and considerations, and we must think carefully about the unintended consequences as well as those intended. A global pause or Moratorium has been called for before there is any clinical application of the CRISPR technology,
Jennifer Doudner forecasts that applications will become available and possibly even approved within the next 10 years. We have a huge responsibility to consider carefully both the unintended consequences as well as the intended impacts of such a scientific breakthrough.
The evening, hosted by Bristows LLP, and chaired by Baroness Joan Bakewell, welcomed four leading scientists to discuss the topic and take part in the debate:
Dr. Helen O’Neill, Lecturer in Reproductive and Molecular Genetics, University College London
Dr. Nessa Carey, Imperial College London and author of Hacking the Code of Life and Junk DNA:
Professor Robin Lovell-Badge, Head of Laboratory of Stem Cell Biology and Developmental Genetics, The Francis Crick Institute
Dr. Rodger Novak, Co-founder and President CRISPR Therapeutics
This was a fascinating and thought provoking debate, which can be viewed in full on YouTube or below.
If you would like to know more you can go to the society's web page by following the link below.
Filter News

Becky’s Story
From dealing with her family's NF1 to improving her fitness and running marathons, have a read of Becky's amazing story here:
Read More
“Charity Shave Off” for NF in Northern Ireland
Janice and her family recently held a charity shave off in Northern Ireland. Find out more about the event here:
Read More
Blackpool Magic Convention 2020
Find out more about the convention in aid of NTUK and how you can get involved here:
Read More
Reflections on 2019
Check out our reflection on what we feel was an incredibly succesful 2019 for the charity:
Read More
Helen’s Story as told by her Mum Pauline
Due to her NF1, Helen has faced several struggles. Mum Pauline has openly shared her daughter's experiences with us here:
Read More
Nicola’s NF2 Journey
Nicola creates her own YouTube videos to help promote NF2 awareness. Find out more about her NF2 journey here:
Read More
Making the Future of Work inclusive of persons with disability
Check out James' recent presentation at a conference in Geneva highlighting issues of "face equality" in the workplace
Read More
The Royal Society - A Quest for the perfect Human…? A debate on the implications of human genome editing
Find out more about the debate recently undertaken at The Royal Society here:
Read More